
When I’m expressing my opinions on music or film or what-have-you, I have a tendency to distort it in either direction. Something is either “the greatest ever” or “the worst ever.” “Best song ever written.” “A complete waste of time and electricity.” I know that I do it and I try not to in my writing. Still, it does creep in there and I have a reputation among my friends for such hyperbole.
So know that, while I am aware of my propensity to embellish, what I am about to say carries not even the slightest hint of exaggeration. I have never been more honest in my life:
If I was forced to live the rest of my life music-free and if I was only allowed one musical recording to listen to, on repeat, for the rest of my natural life, I would pick, without hesitation, the bootleg of Pink Floyd’s November 21, 1970 performance at Montreux Casino in Switzerland. It is my absolute favorite record, legitimate or not, of any band, ever. If I could time travel to any point in human history, I would choose to be present at this gig. I am not fucking kidding.
If you love Pink Floyd but have never heard this particular bootleg, you will lose your mind before the end of “Astonomy Domine.” If you hate Pink Floyd, chances are you will be rethinking your opinion by the end of the show. If you like Pink Floyd, but don’t like Atom Heart Mother, you will be rushing out to purchase five copies of it for each of your CD players after you hear the 14-minute full-length version of “Fat Old Sun.” I would submit it to you that you have no hope of ever truly understanding the band that was Pink Floyd without hearing this recording.
Forget Dark Side of the Moon. There are no synthesizers or backup vocalists here. Just four guys- guitar, bass, organ, and drums- blowing your fucking mind. It’s a professional soundboard recording, commissioned by the band themselves, so you hear absolutely everything. God knows why they chose not to release this show as a live record. The course of music as we know it would have been drastically altered. No band, not even Pink Floyd, has sounded anything like this before or since.
Listen to this alone, on headphones, in the dark, and you will emerge a changed person. Or, better yet, put it on around midnight during your next road trip. Guaranteed that ghoul from Carnival of Souls will show up at your passenger side window. And then you get some blues jams to calm you down. Or freak you out more, I don’t know how you’ll react.
But you’ll never listen to any band, on record or in concert, the same way again. The noisiest noise rock will seem conservative, the most interesting jam rock will sound dull, and the most intricate prog rock will sound overly complicated. You’ll wonder, for at least a moment, why all albums aren’t recorded live. Any band with more than four people will look pompous and silly. The things that used to frighten you will torment you no more. In a nutshell, Smoking Blues will fuck you up.
Sorry if I’m building this up too much for you, but I don’t know if I can. It’s absolutely brilliant and I am as passionate about it as I can possibly be. If you have never had the opportunity to experience the Pink Floyd of 1969-1971, you are missing some of the finest music ever made. Smoking Blues- especially as a companion piece to their Live at Pompeii concert film- is a near-perfect document of a band in their prime.
Pink Floyd - Astronomy Domine.mp3
Download the concert via BitTorrent (note: any recordings that display the date as November 21, 1969 are the same show, they’re just labeled incorrectly)
And, as a bonus, here’s “Embryo” from my favorite video bootleg of the band’s, taken from a performance in Saint Tropez a few months prior to the recording of Smoking Blues. Enjoy.





firewall | 19-Dec-06 at 3:23 pm | Permalink
Luogo interessante, buon disegno, lo gradisco, signore! =)
Caitlin | 02-Mar-07 at 2:51 pm | Permalink
thanx for ur opinion about pink floyd! It gives me the urge to finally listen to their music for the first time!
Jeff W. | 04-Aug-07 at 8:14 pm | Permalink
Your opinion was no exaggeration. That album, and the soundtrack to Live at Pompeii(a copy of which I managed to digitally peel from the video), are about the only music I bother to listen to nowadays. Too bad Roger Waters has his differences with the rest of the group(temporarily put aside in ‘05, when all four appeared together at the Live 8–or was it LiveAid?–concert), otherwise, they could do a set today of those same tunes. “Return to Pompeii,” anyone? This time, though, have the Roman Ampitheatre filled to capacity–trust me, tickets would sell out in mere minutes.
gary | 06-Oct-07 at 1:47 pm | Permalink
excellent
Patrick Bateman | 08-Jan-08 at 12:58 am | Permalink
There are times when things of beauty become apparent to us. Sometimes they happen at the wrong times in our lives. If I heard Smoking Blues when I was younger, I would not have appreciated it. This happened to me at just the right time. I get it. And in getting it, I feel sorry for those who don’t. Then again, beauty is truly in the eye of the beholder. Smoking blues is the first glimpse of the baby’s head–the birth of the great Pink Floyd in all of its glory. How Gilmour’s solo in Fat Old Sun (nod to Echoes @ Pompeii) is not ranked among the best ever is beyond me. Sadly, its not beyond many. My only regret in listening to Smoking Blues is that one realizes it is one of a kind–painting with searchlights the moribund state of creativity in music today. Its much like making love for the last time to a beautiful woman who you know will leave you. You’re not sure it you’re truly better off for doing it.
Kevin farrell | 15-Sep-08 at 6:43 pm | Permalink
Pink Floyd DID change the world with OUTSTANDING MUSIC AND TALENT !!!!